top of page

From our family to yours.

Protection we all count on.

- Matthew Bennett, Owner
My clients are like family; and we treat
them that way.

Matthew began his insurance career in 2010 becoming a partner at Anderson Williamson Insurance Agency. This adventure lead him to become sole owner in 2017 after the retirement of John “Rick” Williamson. 


Matt lives in Xenia with his wife Holly Bledsoe Bennett, which is a lifelong resident of Greene County, along with their daughter Morgan. Prior to insurance Matt attended Ohio University. And after college worked as a consular for Job and Family Services in Ross County , Ohio. From there he left and work with various Tobacco Companies as a sales manager before going into the insurance business. 


Matt is a proud member of Xenia Rotary and sits on the board for Xenia Area Chamber of Commerce. Matt also sits on the Greene County Library Foundation Board and is a commissioner for the City of Xenia Planning and Zoning Commission.


In his free time Matt loves to golf and coach his daughter various sports teams.

Matthew Bennett
CSRM, Principal

Commercial, Home,
Auto, Crop & Farm,

We offer the best coverage at affordable rates.


- Andrew Thielman, Owner
Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.

Andrew lives in Springboro with his wife Nicole Diane (Francis) Thielman, a graduate of Bellbrook High School in 2001, along with their three sons, Hayden, Grayson, and Declan. Prior to insurance Andrew attended Western Michigan University, where he holds degrees in Business Analytics and International Marketing. After college he worked for the Commerce Department, while earning his PGA Class “A” Membership in the Professional Golfers Association of America. Andrew moved to Ohio in 1995 to become the Golf Professional at Country Club of the North, then Dayton Country Club, and afterwards The Golf Club at Yankee Trace, before becoming the General Manager at Golf Galaxy and retiring to being his career in insurance.


Andrew is proud of his affiliation as a past board member of the Kettering-Moraine-Oakwood Chamber of Commerce and Springboro Youth Basketball.


In his free time Andrew loves to teach golf to various youth organizations and coach his sons in all sports that they play. He can also be found rooting for his favorite University of Georgia sports teams!


Commercial, Home,
Auto, Farm,


As independent agents, we  work with many different insurance companies to offer a wide variety of coverage options and price points. We’re committed to maintaining strong relationships with some of the best insurance carriers in the world. Our partners help us provide insurance solutions tailored to the needs of your family and business.

With our connections and knowledge of the market, our agents can often find a better value for your insurance dollar than you might find searching on your own. Our agents do the shopping to find you the right blend of price, coverage, and service. You do the saving.

With help or without

If its after-hours or you feel comfortable getting the claims process started yourself online; please find your carrier's "Submit a Claim" link below and follow their directions. Make sure to have your photos and documentation available.

Please note: if you are new to the claims process or simply prefer that we assist you, please call us directly or use the form below.

For Claims HELP

Thanks! Message sent.


When you need us wE'RE HERE FOR YOU

Call, email or stop in to see us

We welcome you to visit our office. We enjoy meeting our clients to get to know them better and devise the plan that works best for their needs. There are many ways to contact us for service or to receive a quote.

CALL: 937-310-1460

After Hours Emergency?

Andrew 937-545-8145

Matt 937-305-2232

Visit: 64 w. franklin St.

Bellbrook, Ohio 45305

Monday - Friday

8:30 am - 5:00 pm


Thanks! Message sent.

bottom of page